Understand what we can learn from the Bauducco Case and accusations of plagiarism in the advertising industry
To build a successful and creative campaign from scratch, market research is naturally conducted to find potential sources of inspiration. However, there is a clear difference between drawing inspiration and copying elements from external work — and understanding Copyright law is essential to avoid legal risks, such as accusations of plagiarism.
The recent case involving the Bauducco campaign, in partnership with singers Juliette and Duda Beat, reflects what can happen. On October 17, the single "Magia Amarela" was launched as part of a rebranding initiative for the brand famous for its panetones, following a visual identity refresh for the Christmas season. However, the reason for its high numbers was not what was expected — the topic trended after accusations of plagiarism due to similarities with Emicida's song and visual style, AmarElo.
The crime of plagiarism is legally defined in Article 184 of the Penal Code, with penalties ranging from three months to four years of imprisonment or fines, depending on the severity of the offense. It is closely related to another law: the Copyright Law, which provides protection for intellectual works and grants the exclusive right to their use, exploitation, and commercialization.
In other words, even in the Digital Age, exercising caution when using images, music, or other copyrighted elements is essential to prevent future legal issues and protect your brand's reputation.
But what is considered plagiarism?
This violation is defined as the "total or partial reproduction, with direct or indirect profit intent, by any means or process, of an intellectual work, interpretation, performance, or phonogram, without the express authorization of the author, performing artist, producer, as applicable, or their representatives."
In the world of advertising, CONAR (National Advertising Self-Regulation Council) is the regulatory body for the sector, and it has previously received complaints involving brands such as Activia and Boticário.
ABM recommends some best practices to avoid issues like this:
• Always verify the authorship of the content you intend to use;
• Prefer using Creative Commons materials with no usage restrictions within your category, or Public Domain works;
• Always give credit when using sources and references.
Have any questions about this topic? Get in touch with one of ABM's specialists and we will be happy to help!